Thursday, December 30, 2010

It's All About the Corporate Benjamins, Baby: Education, a.k.a., My 2010 Year in Review Post

(This has been cross-posted at All Things Education.)

During 2010, thanks to the work of Lawrence Lessig and Chris Hedges, I became much more aware of the unhealthy corporate influence in American democratic institutions. I put aside my creative writing to launch a series of posts on my more general blog on the topic. I wrote about corporate money in politics and government, after which I took a break to write about the VA-07 congressional electionwriting, and journalism, and to start a blog dedicated to education. I've intended to regularly update my food blog, as well, but the best laid plans. . .

Right before the Christmas holiday, I completed a piece about Teach For America, which I am hoping will be published somewhere bigger (not likely, I know). In the meantime, I was going to use winter break and the grandparental child care that comes with it to write, blog, publish, write, blog, publish. However, as I tried to organize my thinking about the present and future of journalism, of writing as a profession, of teaching as a profession, of public education, and of efforts to reform education, the topics all swirled together to form a toxic sludge of anxiety that, helped along by my kids' germs, rendered me existentially and then physically ill. As miserable as it was, being sick forced me to take a step back and ignore all of it for a number of days. From this pause grew a less fevered end-of-year collection of thoughts about the confluence of corporate influence and public education.

I am vulnerable to conspiracy theorizing about what's currently happening in the name of education reform, and I understand why others are, too--I think, in fact, that democracy benefits from this type of push back. Are the reforms of wealthy and politically connected individuals harmful to the institution of public education? I have said on my education blog and continue to say: yes, that in many cases they are. But are those folks sitting around together and villainously hatching some grand scheme to bring down public education? No, that's way too simplistic of an explanation for what's going on. Furthermore, I'm doubtful that describing problems with their efforts in terms of a conspiracy is productive. The problem with talking like a conspiracy theorist, even if there's at least some truth to what's being said, is that you're likely to be dismissed by the very people you need to be taken seriously by. In that vein, it is equally hysterical and irresponsible to cast teachers and teachers unions as the villainous "deep-pocketed" (ha!) root of all of our nation's problems or even as the root of our education system's problems, or as sitting around conspiring to ruin children's lives because they only care about the "adults." Unfortunately, these seem to be prevailing narratives these days.

Teachers' unions may defend some people who don't deserve defending and they may make mistakes, and yes, there are educators out there who aren't doing their jobs and yes, teachers need fair and rigorous evaluations, but as a group, teachers and their unions are not responsible for how our society has failed us over the past year. Did teachers unions cause twenty-seven plus percent of America's children to live in poverty? No. Have teachers and their unions driven up heath care costs? Do they deny coverage and care to our the most vulnerable among us? Nope. Did teachers and their unions cause our economic system to melt down? No, that was another group of professionals. Did teachers and their unions go start costly and futile wars in Iraq and Afghanistan? Did teachers and their unions create a criminal justice system that disproportionately and often unjustly imprisons poor people and minorities? No, they aren't behind such travesties. Did teachers and their unions fail to recognize the impending dangers of climate change and then sabotage legislation meant to lessen the havoc it's going to reap? No. It's not been teachers or their unions that have done all of these things, but our political leaders, policies, and system. And who is now clearly behind those? Not a bunch of middle class educators, but business, financial, industrial, and corporate interests.

While I don't believe that there is some evil master plan being hatched by the likes of DFER (Democrats for Education Reform), Bill Gates, Eli Broad, and the Waltons, their influence is unhealthy, undemocratic, and dangerous. Teachers unions and organizations like the National Education Association at least are accountable to the systems and large numbers of people they represent, systems and people whose work and studies will be most affected by the reforms being brought. Whom do DFER, Gates, Broad, and the Waltons represent? To whom are they accountable? Were they elected? Since when should a handful of unelected, extraordinarily wealthy people be entrusted to represent the interests of millions of poor, working, and middle class people?

Two of the most egregious examples of corporate influence in education are in higher education. As there is less public funding of public universities, wealthy patrons such as the Koch brothers are stepping in to establish "institutes" that put out research and teachings that serve not the interests of citizens, but the interests of the industries they own. In medical schools and schools of public health, much research on drugs and treatments traditionally funded by public monies is now funded and supervised by the very pharmaceutical companies who stand to reap profits from their successful trials.

In K-12 education, there are not as many cases of such overt conflicts of interest, but I'm afraid we're moving in that direction.  Gates, Broad, and the Waltons support market-based reforms that would include mayoral takeovers, vast expansion of charter schools (which are public schools that can be run in some instances as private institutions), the de-professionalization of teaching, and CEO-like leadership of schools and school systems, and they are pouring money into the system to see such reforms actualized. Influential organizations with deceptively neutral-sounding names such as right-wing ideologue Jeanne Allen's Center for Education Reform directly promote privatizing our public education system. As they already have in New York City Public Schools, test prep companies such as Kaplan (which is owned by the pro-corporate education reform Washington Post) stand to make millions from the new education reformers' policies which rely heavily on standardized tests.

As public schools are being told by Secretary of Education Arne Duncan to do "more with less" and as school budgets are being reduced and reduced and stimulus money runs out, with no enthusiasm for alternative means of raising revenues, the private sector is stepping to fill in the gaps often with strings attached, shaping our education system to their liking, whether its largesse benefits its supposed recipients or not. What's about to happen in Los Angeles Unified School District is only the tip of the iceberg.

An example of private takeover of public schools already in progress is in DC. The DC Public Education Fund is privately run on private donations with no public oversight, and very little of the money that's raised goes directly into the D.C. Public Schools' budget or is dispersed by those appointed to run the schools; yet, the fund directly influences outcomes in public schools. For example, the organization funded IMPACT, DC's controversial new evaluation system, teacher bonuses, as well as the infamous new contracts with teachers. During the negotiations, then-Chancellor Rhee stated that if she wasn't going to be around later, a.k.a., if Adrian Fenty didn't get re-elected, that the money raised for the teacher contracts would go, too. That is a clear example of private interests using private money to influence public elections and public policy. When public money is used to fund public schools, such blackmail can't take place, at least not legally. Much more democratic would be for the wealthy individuals who are behind such efforts to be taxed appropriately with the tax revenues funding social and educational programs vetted by democratically elected and appointed officials.

The Gates Foundation and the DC Public Education Fund have their hands in many places, and surely, not all of them are harmful to public education, but when I read Gates's thoughts and ideas about education, for example in these interviews about teaching in Parade and Newsweek, I'm horrified. (I'm also horrified about what such coverage means about the state of education journalism, but that's another story.) Not only has Gates not been elected or appointed by an elected official, he speaks simplistically and ignorantly about education even just at the level of basic facts, and his ideas have not been shown to work or improve the systems they impact.

While Eli Broad is no right-wing ideologue, his private education foundation and school leadership training centers have profound impacts on the public systems they're meant to reform. This New Yorker article about Eli Broad's influence in the Los Angeles art world is very instructive on Broad's approach to philanthropy. Broad has good intentions and interesting ideas, enlarging the arts scene in LA and making art exhibitions more accessible, for example. But he doesn't simply give money directly to art institutions or entrust the experts with funding; rather, he has to own and control the institutions, even if that means promoting poor practices or destroying the institutions. I can only imagine that a similar dynamic occurs in the Broads' education philanthropies.

If Gates, Broad, the Waltons, and the hedge funders behind DFER weren't rich, would they be listened to? Why are they being listened to now? Why are such a small group of extraordinarily wealthy individuals allowed to wield so much power and control over education policy? This is at the expense of democracy. Obama has rightly stated grave concerns with the Supreme Court's Citizens United ruling. Why is he not concerned with big money in our public education system? Why does he, in fact, welcome it? Is corporate influence any less problematic in the halls of our schools than it is in our halls of government?

One need not launch ad hominem attacks, speak of ethical dilemmas, or list the hypocrises of these education reformers. All Americans, regardless of political affiliation and educational ideology, can agree that our great nation was founded on the ideals of democracy. Corporate money and influence in our public democratic institutions, especially in our public schools, corrodes and corrupts our democracy. Anti-democratic forces are un-American. A healthy democracy requires a well and publicly financed, equitable public education system. Unfortunately, that's not what the Obama administration and the particular education reformers they throw their support behind are going to produce. Unchecked private and corporate influence in our public education system is as big a threat to our democracy as the unchecked corporate influence is in our political system. In fact, they are one in the same. Our public schools should no more belong to Gates, Broad, Bush, or any DFER member as they do to any taxpayer and any citizen; it is from them we must take our country, our democracy, and our schools back.


UPDATE 1/6/11: Too bad I didn't see this brilliant piece by writer Joanne Barkan before I posted this. I could have saved myself the trouble--it's a much better, more comprehensive piece on the problems with education philanthropy than anything I have ever written. Read it in Dissent Magazine or in truthout.

32 comments:

grocery delivery Lahore said...

We provide home delivery of the freshest fresh fruits and vegetables,
and grocery delivery in Lahore .

Grocery Near Me said...

Buy grocery near me . Choose from 1,000+ products from Fresh Fruits, Vegetables, Bakery Products, Meat & Poultry. Snacks, Household Cleaning Items & Much More. Fresh Vegetables & Fruits. Bakery items. Office supplies. Meat One. Neighborhoods: Gulberg, DHA, Jauhar Town, Model Town.

Pickup for Rent in Arabian Ranches said...

office & home shifting services. Pickup for Rent in Arabian Ranches Dubai UAE. Hire 5 Ton, 7 Ton, 10 Ton Pickup for Rent Dubai & Trailer Truck Rental Dubai. pickup for rent in mirdif. pickup for rent in jvc. pickup for rent in al barsha. pickup for rent in sports city. pickup for rent in silicon oasis. pickup for rent in dubai .We provide reliable & cost effective pickup rental services as per your business.

Trailer Rental Dubai said...

Trailer Rental Dubai - Trailer Truck for Rent in UAE 0558902008
Get Heavy Trailer Truck for Rent in UAE, Trailer Rental Dubai , Trailer for Rent in Sharjah, Trailer Truck for Rent Call: 055 890 2008. Trailer truck for rent in uae, trailer for rent in sharjah, trailer rental abu dhabi.

Pickup for Rent in Elite Residence Dubai: said...

Noor Ahmed Transports LLC provides 3 Ton to 10 Ton Pickup Truck Rental Dubai. Truck Rental Dubai UAE. Pickup Truck Service and all Logistics Movers and Packers services – Trailer Truck for Rent Dubai, for Commercial Transportation, Home/Office Shifting, Man with van service in Dubai. We are here to serve you. We have big and small moving vans, Pickup Truck for Moving, Pickup Rental Dubai for Home shifting, Office shifting, Man with a van, Pickup for Rent in Elite Residence Dubai . Truck Rent in Dubai, Pickup Truck rental Dubai and Dubai Movers & Packers.

Pickup for Rent in Emirates Hill Dubai said...

Noor Ahmed Transports LLC provides 3 Ton to 10 Ton
Pickup for Rent in Emirates Hill Dubai . Truck Rental Dubai UAE. Pickup Truck Service and all Logistics Movers and Packers services – Trailer Truck for Rent Dubai, for Commercial Transportation, Home/Office Shifting, Man with van service in Dubai. We are here to serve you. We have big and small moving vans, Pickup Truck for Moving, Pickup Rental Dubai for Home shifting, Office shifting, Man with a van, Pickup for rent in Dubai, Truck Rent in Dubai, Pickup Truck rental Dubai and Dubai Movers & Packers.We provide pickup trucks for rent in Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Ras Al Khaimah from Sharjah. Ton 3 and 7 Ton and 10 Ton Pickup Available for rental. We have a team of experienced drivers available.

Pickup For Rent in Internet City Dubai said...

Pickup For Rent in Internet City Dubai , Pickup Truck and Trailers for rent or lease on a nationwide basis. If your company needs pickup Trucks or trailers on a daily, weekly, monthly or yearly lease/rental Noor Ahmed Transports can provide those in a timely manner either delivered or your pickup with your drivers. With over 20 years of experience in knowing what fits your needs we have old, new and reconditioned flatbed trailers and pickup Trucks at your disposal.

Best Painting services in Dubai said...

Mumtaz Hussain Technical Services llc is a villa painting services, painting services in dubai marina, best painting company dubai , wall painting services, studio painting in dubai, home painting services, painting walls service, painting services in abu dhabi.

Trailer Rental Abu Dhabi said...

Noor Ahmed Transport is a professional professional
trailer rental in Dubai , UAE. We have the best performing and bard new vehicles for long-distance and heavy load transportation all over UAE. Our goal is to have a personalized, flexible, and professional service when dealing with our clients for domestic and commercial transportation needs. Noor Ahmed Transports’ modern fleet of transport Trucks and Trailers in wide range and capacity, including everything from 1 Ton Pickup Truck to Flatbed Trailers.

Trailer Rental Abu Dhabi said...

Noor Ahmed Transport is a professional professional
trailer rental in Dubai , UAE. We have the best performing and bard new vehicles for long-distance and heavy load transportation all over UAE. Our goal is to have a personalized, flexible, and professional service when dealing with our clients for domestic and commercial transportation needs. Noor Ahmed Transports’ modern fleet of transport Trucks and Trailers in wide range and capacity, including everything from 1 Ton Pickup Truck to Flatbed Trailers.

Joseph Edward said...

I'm presently on a temporary permit and have finished my alumni program for SPED. Notwithstanding, because of unexpected reasons I couldn't finish the understudy training segment of my GMU program. Is there an approach to in any case get a full permit in Virginia that could then exchange to another state? Much appreciated!
Painter Ellicott City

grocery delivery near me said...

Order grocery delivery near me Online Get Farm-Fresh Fruits & Vegetables Delivered To Your Door Step with fast delivery. Online Shopping on nukarshop.pk for Best Deals on Household & Personal, Cooking Items & Much More. Register Online. Sign Up For Newsletter. Download Mobile App.

online maintenance services said...

Nukarshop provides a variety of services including renovation, and repair & online maintenance services. We offer the below-mentioned services with a 100% guarantee of customer satisfaction.Plumber Services, Cleaning Services,Painter Services,Electrician Services, Ac services and handyman services.

Trailer Truck for Rent in UAE said...

Trucks & Trailer for Rent in UAE.We offer brand new flat Trailers for Cheap Rentals in all over UAE. Need to transport some cargo and you are looking for a truck? We offer the best rental services for flat trailers and other solutions for transport and logistic services. Flat trailer rental in uae, trailer rental dubai, tipper trailer for rent, trailer for rent in sharjah, trailer rental abu dhabi, trailer rental dubai to saudi.

Trailer Truck for Rent in UAE said...

Trailer Truck for Rent in UAE. We have the best performing and new vehicles for significant length and weighty burden transportation all over UAE. We will probably have a customized, adaptable, and proficient assistance when managing our customers. Noor Ahmed Transports’ advanced armada of hefty vehicle trucks and trailers in wide reach and limit, including everything from 3 Ton Pickup Truck to Flatbed Trailers.

Joseph Edward said...

Likewise, training has become an industry. The objective isn't to instruct any longer, all it's taking care of a framework swelled with obscure directors and ruthless project workers offering disgraceful items and administrations.
House Painter Germantown

Storage services in Dubai said...

We offers a comprehensive range of Technical Services for domestic and commercial properties at a reasonable price in all over UAE. We are trusted and reliable technical services provider who serve customers in the Dubai as well as throughout United Arab Emirates. We have extensive experience of domestic and business Technical Services and no job is too small. Our customers value our professionalism, work ethic and our competitive prices. We offer these services.
Painting Contracting Services, Building Cleaning Services, Carpentry & Flooring Contracting, Floor and Wall Tiling Works, Storage services , Engraving & Ornamentation Works, Post Construction Cleaning Service, and Pickup Truck Hire/Moving & Shifting Service.

safe driver dubai said...

Safe Driver Dubai is your all-inclusive resource when you are searching for the Safe Driver Service Dubai. We have aptitude in giving you the best wellbeing driving administrations. At the point when you are searching for a dependable individual to comfort drive for you or your friends and family, our best protected Safe Drivers in Dubai will meet your interests. We spend significant time in offering security driver administrations. You can rely on us while chasing for the best protected driver organization in UAE.

Dubai Packers and Movers said...

10 ton pickup for rent in Dubai

https://dubaimoversandpackers.com/

Dubai Movers and Packers is one of the leading relocation and mover companies in Dubai and come fully equipped with a team of relocation/movers specialists and moving consultants.Office movers dubai a local office move, inter-state or an international relocation, our furniture movers in Dubai has the expertise, skill and resources to offer a seamless office move dubai without disruption or distraction of your day to day work. Our office moving consultants are highly qualified and trained to relocate you office in dubai with minimal hassle to your office equipment, computers, servers, furniture, electronic systems, libraries, files and records in an organized manner. Our aim is to avoid transitional issues and minimize downtime between the office moves in dubai.

Aqsa Imran said...

Self Storage Service
Assuming you are on the chase after a top financial plan storage space in Dubai that wont beg to be spent , we Self Storage Dubai gathered together the least expensive storage spaces in every city in Dubai.

It is UAE based quickest moving supplies company ( 2 hours conveyance ) moving boxes , freight boxes , air pockets wrap , tape and so forth .

One of the expert pressing trucking organizations in Dubai. Proficient staff for house moving , office moving , prepared vehicles and constant help in UAE

Aqsa Imran said...

Best Self Storage Dubai
Assuming you are on the chase after a top financial plan storage space in Dubai that wont beg to be spent , we Self Storage Dubai gathered together the least expensive storage spaces in every city in Dubai.

It is UAE based quickest moving supplies company ( 2 hours conveyance ) moving boxes , freight boxes , air pockets wrap , tape and so forth .

One of the expert pressing trucking organizations in Dubai. Proficient staff for house moving , office moving , prepared vehicles and constant help in UAE

Movers And Packers in Dubai said...

Globexshipping Dubai is one of the best movers and packers in Dubai. You can get free moving quotes from best Movers in Dubai, by contacting +971586191901

Globexshipping Movers is one of the top choices for packing and moving companies in Dubai. While they are based in Dubai, they offer house moving services across in UAE.

Aqsa Imran said...

Fruit Basket For Gift

Want to send a fruit gift to your beloved ones? Or do you want to buy fresh vegetables? Fruitoye.pk is famous for its trade of fresh fruits and nd vegetables. We have the highest quality standards from the best farms. We have gained our fame by delivering healthy food.
We are also delivering any type of
meats and vegetables
Breakfast and dairy
Beverages
Bread and bakery
Frozen food
Biscuits and snacks
Grocery and staples

So grab your mobile phones or laptops and contact us online.
Serving you the highest quality food

Aqsa Imran said...

Fruit Basket Online Pakistan
Fruitoye.pk is a distributor of fresh fruits and vegetables of high quality and a popular market experience. Fruit Mart LLC has a very long list and history containing a thousand varieties of fresh fruits and vegetables from around the world divided into the excellent quality and attractive value. Customers can taste the quality of the service and the freshness of the fruit and vegetables in every order they receive. You want to give your loved ones something healthy, refreshing, and tasty and then a fruit basket, in which to add fruits such as green apples, grapes, bananas, oranges, plums, kiwi, and mangoes. A fruit basket full of healthy, fresh, and juicy fruit will look great if you have the gift of adding fun to your loved one’s special event..

Aqsa Imran said...


eCommerce Services Agency
commerceK2 is a leading digital organization, we have been leading businesses in the path of digital transformation. We specialize in Ecommerce Strategy | Development of Ecommerce Solutions | eCommerce Process Automation | eCommerce SEO | Search Marketing | Social Media | Hosting & Security. We are among the top 3% of global agencies that proudly hold the client's needs.

Aqsa Imran said...


Digital Marketing Agency Lahore
commerceK2 is a leading digital organization, we have been leading businesses in the path of digital transformation. We specialize in Ecommerce Strategy | Development of Ecommerce Solutions | eCommerce Process Automation | eCommerce SEO | Search Marketing | Social Media | Hosting & Security. We are among the top 3% of global agencies that proudly hold the client's needs.

Aqsa Imran said...

Designated Driver Dubai
High-quality secure motive force Dubai which take you and your car to your destination, if you are in search for the best safe driver Dubai provider, then we have got expertise in providing you the weightier protection using services. While you are looking for a dependable man or woman to repletion momentum for you or your family, our high-quality safe driver Dubai service. Will virtually meet your issues. We concentrate on offering the best safe driver Dubai service

TutorExpertz said...

Are you facing a travel date only to find that you’re without a passport or your old passport has expired? Don’t worry, even if you are traveling tomorrow, we can help. Our 24 hour passport and travel visa service makes certain that your plane, car, or ship doesn’t leave without you.

Best Local Movers in Dubai said...

Hiring a professional movers and packers company in dubai can help quick transportation and settlement of goods without you having to worry. It’s an easy process, as all your responsibilities are transferred to the service providing company.

Technical UAE said...

Are you need best expert for Laptop Repair Dubai? Uaetechnician company provides best expert Call us toll-free number 045864033

Home Appliances said...

Do you need HAndyman Near Me for your Home Appliances? We Provide the Best Handyman Services Near You

Local Movers in Dubai said...

The good thing behind hiring professional Dubai movers and packers company is that they can get rid of your stress.